Big Picture Big Sound

Humanity has long expressed its fear and curiosity with death through art and culture. There are countless films, books, plays, and television shows exploring that "undiscovered country from whose bourn no traveler returns." Concurrently, many beloved works delve into our fascination with lost love and the "what ifs" of prior life choices. David Freyne's "Eternity" blends these two premises into a romantic comedy that proves light-hearted yet surprisingly weighty.

Elizabeth Olsen and Miles Teller play Joan and Larry, a long-married couple introduced in a bicker-filled car ride to the gender reveal party of one of their grandchildren. This bickering is not acidic or hateful; it is the patter of a lived-in, familiar interaction, even though differences of opinion remain clear. These two have gone the distance together, planning to reach "The End" side by side. Joan's illness has them expecting her to finish the race first, but Larry's indulgence in pretzels lands him at The Junction - the arrival point for the recently deceased - before her.

The Junction is a quaint, manufactured-feeling place, like a hotel and convention center designed with just a touch of Wes Anderson's twee sensibility, where an endless array of possible eternal afterlives is on offer. Larry's Afterlife Coordinator Anna (Da'Vine Joy Randolph) explains the rules and coaxes him toward choosing one of those eternities - Larry always did want to go to the beach - but he must decide within a week. Yet all Larry wants is Joan; he has only ever known life with her, and death is no different.

Larry isn't the only one searching for Joan, however. Her first husband Luke (Callum Turner), killed decades earlier in the Korean War, has been waiting in the Junction for sixty years. Coincidentally, Luke's Afterlife Coordinator Ryan (John Early) is also Joan's AC, and he's firmly #teamLuke. What follows is a funny, sometimes frustrating duel between two men vying for Joan's hand in eternity.

Joan is the emotional core of this trio, and Olsen conveys the wide range of feelings she confronts, from shock to awe, happiness to sadness, lovesickness to dread. She inhabits Joan with exasperated warmth toward Larry, balanced against wide-eyed wonder toward Luke, as expected when re-encountering someone frozen in memory. She has genuine chemistry with each, selling the difficulty of her plight. Teller embodies the everyman archetype convincingly, imbuing Larry with loyalty and charm toward Joan and a testy competitiveness toward Luke. Despite Luke fitting the description of the dream guy, Teller's Larry is still undeniably handsome.

Turner, meanwhile, faces the most difficult angle. Yes, Luke is the literal man of Joan's dreams, but "Eternity" traps him in that framework, despite intriguing peripheral details about his sixty-year wait. This robs him of nuance and development, leaving him to gaze intensely at Joan while side-eyeing Larry - an unfortunate limitation for Turner. Early and Randolph demonstrate sharp comic timing, adding levity and empathy for their charges while delivering natural exposition to help both characters (and the audience) navigate the strange rules of this afterlife.

Behind the camera, director David Freyne shows a steady hand, maintaining a consistent tone that prevents the high-concept premise from collapsing into farce. Working from Pat Cunnane's celebrated Black List script, Freyne conveys the absurdity of this bureaucracy of death without losing sight of the human stakes, calling to mind the classic "Defending Your Life." The film's visual language is equally distinct: cinematographer Ole Bratt Birkeland bathes The Junction in a soft, hyper-real light that complements the production design's mid-century aesthetic, blending pastels with earth tones. This stylized approach underscores the artificiality of this purgatory, creating a visual disconnect that effectively reflects Larry and Joan's sense of displacement, aided by David Fleming's score, which deftly balances the whimsy of the setting with the melancholy of the situation.

"Eternity" teases out fascinating ideas as the love triangle unfolds. The notion of spending infinity at the beach or in a mountain cabin sounds pleasant - but it is all you will ever know, forever. Is that truly what you want? Let's all revisit "The Good Place" and consider the implications. The many available eternities are richly detailed and often hilarious; I long for a website indexing them all. Spotting more details in this space will be a prime reward for repeat viewing.

The implications of Joan and Luke's reunion recall the iconic closing shot of "The Graduate," with Ben and Elaine settling into the gravity of what just happened. Luke has longed for Joan for decades, but can they start anew armed only with the memory of their brief beginning before his death? The sizzle is there, but is there any steak? Olsen shines as she shoulders the burden of these moments, salvaging the thinness of Luke's characterization. Joan's agency in this "Very Important Decision" remains central, and the film carefully weighs that against the core narrative conflict of Luke and Larry's claims to her eternal hand.

On the surface, "Eternity" appears to be a sweet, simple rom-com, but it delivers a much more interesting payoff. It taps deep philosophical notions, interrogating idealized love versus actualized love, memory versus identity, selfishness versus selflessness. These ideas unfold in a visually engaging world with characters you enjoy watching. Whether its questions strike you as existentially terrifying is left to the viewer. Either way, it makes for a compelling film - one best followed by a spirited post-viewing discussion with friends over in the Eternity of Infinite Pizza.