bigpicturebigsound.com - The site for Home Theater and Movie Reviews
Forum | About Us | Contact Us | Shop With Us | Site Map | Search
Home
 
 Movies
 Reviews
 High Fives
 News
 Links
 Editorials
 
 Home Theater
 Ask The Expert
 Reviews
 How To
 News and Show Reports
 Links
 Deals
 
 Blu-ray Disc and DVD
 Blu-ray Disc Reviews
 DVD Reviews
Search
RSS
 
 Get Homepage Headlines
  Add to Google RSS feed Add to My Yahoo!
 Get Movie Reviews
  Add to Google RSS feed Add to My Yahoo!
 Get Home Theater Headlines
  Add to Google RSS feed Add to My Yahoo!
  
 Big Picture Big Sound Apple Widgets!
 Follow us on Twitter!
  
 

Blu-ray Disc and DVD : Blu-ray Disc Reviews Published: 2009-11-01 - 11:10:32

UP Blu-ray Review By Chris Chiarella

Overall Rating (out of four):
Email this article
Printer friendly page
 

The Movie

Pixar movies are uniquely capable of an emotional sucker punch, brilliantly written tales of humanity in the guise of the colorful antics of talking toys, insects and fish. UP is in fact "mundane" on the surface, it's about a bunch of people and might even have been filmable in live action, but once the state-of-the-art digital animation tricks us into lowering out guard, POW! We are blindsided by one of the most beautiful, classic and touching love stories ever.

And that's just the opening montage.

Zoom ahead to the present day, and widower Carl Fredrickson (voice of Ed Asner), a cranky old soul from the "You kids stay out of my yard!" school, is being forced to leave the home he's lived in since his wedding day, decades earlier. Rather than go quietly, he has The Big Idea and jiggers a way to make his house fly away, headed down to South America to keep a promise he made to his childhood sweetheart. Once there, all manner of surprises unfold. I'm leaving out a lot, because you really need to see UP for yourself. It's all about experiencing the adventure firsthand.

Be sure to read Karen Dahlstrom's review of UP, too.

The Picture

The crisp, high-def image is presented in a home theater-perfect 1.78:1, with a level of detail that simply begs to be stared at. Carl's stubble can be seen growing ever so subtly during his three-day adventure, and when we see him as a boy, quick eyes will note his cheek blushing ever so fleetingly when a young girl takes his hand for the first time. Textures are masterfully rendered, particularly in the clothing (there's a rapid sequence of his different neckties being knotted, and we can almost believe they are real silk), but elsewhere too, with a look that borders on photo-realism. Very faint ringing appears here and there, but ultimately the animation is not evolutionary as some Pixar films have been, more of an admirable plateau.

The Sound
Up-BD-WEB_2.jpg

The accompanying DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack is sharp and often bold, deftly utilized as yet another storytelling tool. Early on, the virtual camera pulls back from Carl's front porch to reveal the enormous construction site that surrounds him, and the soundfield suddenly expands to envelop us then remains active throughout the scene.

Thunderstorms, particularly the first one that hurries Carl on his way, are appropriately intimidating, enhanced with rear-channel rain. An incidental swarm of insects snaps our dormant speakers back to life, while the kid swinging through a canyon on a rope offers smooth inter-channel phasing. Huge rock towers toppling and a giant airship demand an able subwoofer, and the climactic battle (which gives new meaning to the term "dogfight") is every bit as dynamic as it should be as the final thrill on such a ride.

The Extras

The movie can be watched in "Cine-Explore" mode, which combines audio commentary from director Pete Docter and co-director Bob Peterson with video windows, often more than one on screen simultaneously, sharing photos and a lot of production art. The commentary portion has even been translated into spoken Spanish and French!

The theatrically released animated short, "Partly Cloudy" (six minutes) is joined by the new "Dug's Special Mission" (five minutes) which--much like "Jack-Jack Attack" on The Incredibles--adds backstory to a moment from the film. "Adventure is Out There" (22 minutes) is a travel log of sorts for the filmmakers' field trip to the actual "tabletop mountains" location borrowed for the movie. Alternate Scene: "The Many Endings of Muntz" shares elaborate storyboards and discussions regarding different approaches to the villain's demise (five minutes). Disc One is also where we will also find a Pixar-themed home theater calibration tool.

Disc Two begins with a collection of short documentary featurettes (five to nine minutes each) that focus on specific characters or aspects of the inspirations and perspiration of this production: "Geriatric Hero," "Canine Companions," "Russell, Wilderness Explorer," "Our Giant Flightless Friend, Kevin," "Homemakers of Pixar," "Balloons and Flight" and "Composing for Characters." Another alternate scene, "Married Life," shows a very different (funnier but not quite as endearing) approach to the all-important opening sequence (nine minutes). And the UO promo montage series assembles many brief animations starring characters from the film, six minutes total.

All of these extras are in HD.

Disc 1 is BD-Live-enabled, as is the Global Guardian game on Disc Two, where we earn virtual badges by answering geography questions. Disc Three is a DVD of the movie with select bonus features, and disc four carries a Digital Copy of Up for either iTunes or Windows Media. 

Final Thoughts

If your emotions survive the first 11 minutes, you're home free (well, except for the turning point that takes us from Act II to Act III...) and primed to enjoy a moving tale of enduring love and new beginnings, with plenty of chases and kid-friendly humor along the way.

Product Details

  • Voice Actors: Ed Asner, Christopher Plummer, Jordan Nagai, Bob Peterson, Delroy Lindo, Jerome Ranft, John Ratzenberger, Elie Docter, David Kaye
  • Director/Co-Director: Pete Docter/Bob Peterson
  • Audio Format/Languages: DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 (English), DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 (English), Dolby Digital 5.1 EX (French, Spanish), Dolby Digital 2.0 (English Descriptive Video Service)
  • Subtitles: English SDH, French, Spanish
  • Aspect Ratio: 1.78:1
  • Number of discs: 4
  • Rating: PG
  • Studio: Walt Disney
  • Release Date: November 10, 2009
  • Run Time: 96 minutes
  • List Price: $45.99
  • Extras:
    • "Cine-Explore" BonusView commentary by Pete Docter and Bob Peterson
    • "Partly Cloudy" animated short
    • "Dug's Special Mission" animated short
    • Alternate Scene: "The Many Endings of Muntz"
    • Alternate Scene: "Married Life"
    • Up Promo montage
    • "Adventure is Out There"
    • "Geriatric Hero"
    • "Canine Companions"
    • "Russell wilderness Explorer"
    • "Our Giant Flightless Friend, Kevin"
    • "Homemakers of Pixar"
    • "Balloons and Flight"
    • "Composing for Characters"
    • Global Guardian interactive game
    • BD-Live
Where to Buy:

Overall
Video
Audio
Movie
Extras


Discuss this in the Forum

Last Updated: 2009-11-01 14:46:29
© 2005-2009 Big Picture Big Sound. No use or reprinting of content without permission.
Some movie photos courtesy of imdb.com
All ratings out of four stars | Privacy Statement | Online Shopping

Top of Page

FORUM
Discuss any of our articles, or just tell us what's on your mind in the Big Picture Big Sound Forum!
Latest Headlines
Paper Heart Blu-ray
North by Northwest Blu-ray
Food, Inc. Blu-ray
Blues at Montreux Blu-ray
Fight Club Blu-ray
Leon: The Professional Blu-ray
The Answer Man Blu-ray
Angels & Demons Blu-ray
Marilyn Manson: Guns, God, and Government - Live in L.A. Blu-ray
Billy Idol: In Super Overdrive Live Blu-ray